We tried an agency once. The guy was rubbish.

I hear this one a lot. Most weeks, if I’m honest. Over the last 23 years in recruitment making business development calls, I think I’ve heard most objections, and “we had a bad hire through a recruitment agency” has been a constant in my ‘Top 3’.

“We used an agency before. The guy didn’t last four months. Waste of money.”

And look, I totally understand. A bad hire costs you. The fee, the time, the months of somebody not quite doing the job, and then you’re back to square one. Nobody wants to sign up for that twice.

But there’s a question I always want to ask, and usually I bite my tongue. Did you interview them?

Because somebody did. Somebody sat across a table, or on a Teams call, and thought they were worth hiring. The agency didn’t turn up at your door with them holding a gun to your head.

You could have said no.

I’m not saying that to point the finger. Well, maybe a wee bit. Mostly it’s because if we write a bad hire off as “the agency’s fault”, we miss what actually went wrong. And it’ll go wrong again with the next agency. Or without one.

So where does it break down? In my experience it’s usually one of two places.

The first five minutes

Here’s how a lot of vacancies start. A hiring manager picks up the phone to a recruiter. “Yeah, I’ve got a role. Don’t really have time to chat, I’ll email the spec over. It’s about 50K.”

That’s it. That’s the brief.

Now the recruiter’s working off a job description that was maybe written three years ago, by a different hiring manager. The skillset and experience within the team are completely different so half the “essential” stuff isn’t essential. Let the recruiter push back on it and most of it falls over. And the thing you care about most, the thing that’ll make or break the hire, isn’t in there at all. It’s in your head. 

Your commitment to properly brief your recruiter fixes most of that. Honestly. What does good look like six months in? Why did the last person leave? Who are they working with day to day? What would make you bin a CV straight away? If your next hire is important to get right (as it obviously will be), then you will stand a far better chance of doing so if you meet your recruiter, show them where their candidate will be working, give them as much information as you possibly can. If you’ve worked with this recruiter before and they know your team culture, then maybe you can get away with a 20-to-30-minute phone call. Either way, the more time you put in at the start, the less you’ll waste later on wrong CVs, or worse, the wrong hire.

That’s on the recruiter as much as the client, by the way. A good recruiter should be saying “I’m not starting on this until we’ve had a proper conversation.” I do. Not every client loves it at first. They tend to come round when the first CVs land and they’re actually relevant.

The Friday afternoon CV

The other one is less obvious, and it’s not always the recruiter’s fault.

Most agencies run on KPIs. Calls made, new vacancies, CVs sent are all tracked weekly. So, picture a recruiter on a Thursday night who’s five CVs short of target. What happens on the Friday?

CVs go out. Not necessarily the right CVs. Just CVs.

I’ve been in those offices. I’ve felt that pressure. You end up sending someone who’s “close enough”, because close enough hits the number. Missing the number means a Monday morning chat with your manager that you really don’t want.

Then somebody on the client side reads that CV, has a gap to fill, and thinks… “yeah, maybe.”

Why I work the way I do

This is one benefit of working solo. There’s nobody standing behind me with a stick if I don’t send enough CVs this week.

I’d rather send you nothing than send you someone I don’t believe in. Even better, I’d much rather send two people who are genuinely right than six who are “sort of fine”. You’re busy. You shouldn’t have to wade through mediocre to find good.

Most of the roles I work on are in engineering and manufacturing across Scotland and the North of England, often in small teams, where one wrong hire gets felt by everyone.

Have you got a bus pass?

Think of it this way. If you bought a dodgy car from a dodgy salesman, and it conked out a few months later, you’d be absolutely raging. Fair enough. But did you decide that was it, no more cars, you’ll get the bus for the rest of your life? Of course you didn’t. You bought another one. You might’ve kicked the tyres a wee bit harder, asked a few more questions, but you did buy another car.

So, if you’ve been burned before…

It happens more than it should. But before you write agencies off altogether, have a think about how that last one started. Did you get a proper briefing call or meeting? Were you sent a shortlist, or a pile? And when you said yes to that candidate, what was it you saw?

None of that is about blame. It’s about making sure the next one sticks. 

If you fancy trying it a different way, give me a shout. I’ll want a proper chat first, mind.